February 5, 2010
Abra Kadabra attempts to steal the contents of a museum celebrating history's greatest magicians, when Batman brings his old friend Zatanna in order to thwart him and his army of mind controlled slaves.
The Spectre and the Phantom Stranger make a bet on Bruce Wayne's soul, concerning how he will deal with the information of the man who killed his parents, Thomas Wayne and Martha Wayne. Batman finds the culprit is Joe Chill, who is auctioning off a highly powerful weapon to several of Batman's rogues.
- The adult Bruce Wayne's face is seen for the first time in the series.
- Uncredited/silent villains: Mr. Zero/Mr. Freeze, Two-Face, Mad Hatter, Poison Ivy, Penguin, Solomon Grundy
- Diedrich Bader as Batman/Solomon Grundy
- Jennifer Hale as Zatanna/Poison Ivy
- Jeff Bennett as Abra Kadabra/Joker
- Kevin Conroy as Phantom Stranger
- Mark Hamill as Spectre
- Adam West as Thomas Wayne
- Julie Newmar as Martha Wayne
- Zachary Gordon as Young Bruce
- Peter Onorati as Joe Chill
- Richard Moll as Moxon